Iomsra All articles
Lifestyle

The Grievance Section: Inside 2026’s Bad-Book Clubs

Iomsra
The Grievance Section: Inside 2026’s Bad-Book Clubs

Photo: PattayaPatrol, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Picture a Tuesday night in a Denver bar: eight people are arguing about a sentence. It’s a long one—about 90 words—from a self-published thriller in which a detective “smelled the evidence with his eyes.” Nobody is furious. Everybody is delighted. This is not a typical book club. It’s a bad-book club, one of a growing number of US meetups devoted to reading deliberately terrible books and then gathering to roast them.

Forget the bestseller list. These groups hunt for one-star classics: celebrity memoirs that read like a burned-out LinkedIn post, sci-fi epics with 14-page prologues, romance novels where the meet-cute happens at a funeral and the author forgets the deceased’s name by chapter four. The point isn’t to be cruel. It’s to turn the lonely act of reading into a group sport—part literary critique, part comedy show, part support group for anyone who has ever hate-finished a book out of sheer stubbornness.

The Appeal of a Shared Flop

Reading a bad book alone can feel like a personal failure. Reading one with 12 other people who also highlighted the same absurd sentence? That’s entertainment. Organizers say the format scratches an itch that polished bestsellers can’t: the joy of collective disbelief. When everyone agrees the prose is a disaster, there’s no pressure to be smart or tasteful. You’re not there to impress anyone with your literary takes. You’re there to point at a paragraph and say, “What is happening here?”

It also solves a quiet problem in contemporary reading culture: the obligation to like the right things. Book clubs have long been social spaces, but they can also turn into homework. The bad-book club flips that script. Nobody is performing sophistication. They’re performing bewilderment.

How a Bad-Book Club Actually Works

Most groups follow a loose blueprint. A host picks the book—often from a thrift store, a library sale, or the deepest trenches of self-publishing. The selection has to be genuinely strange, not just divisive. A controversial literary novel won’t cut it. The sweet spot is a book that fails in spectacular, quotable ways.

Members read it (or at least get far enough to have opinions), then meet in person or over video. The discussion has the rhythm of a comedy roast: favorite terrible lines, plot holes you could park a truck in, characters who change names halfway through. Some clubs bring printed excerpts. Others award small prizes for the worst metaphor. One Minneapolis group has been known to hand out a plastic crown to whoever finds the most unnecessary semicolon. The details vary, but the spirit is consistent: the book is the villain, and everyone else is in on the joke.

The Rules of the Roast

Bad-book clubs tend to be more organized than they sound. The rules usually go something like this:

  1. Roast the book, not the author. No personal attacks, no online pile-ons. The target is the text.
  2. Finish it—or at least try. You can’t fake your outrage.
  3. Bring receipts. A vague “it was bad” won’t fly. Quote the offending sentence.
  4. Defend it once. Some clubs require a brief “designated apologist” segment, where one member has to argue the book’s merits. It’s harder than it sounds.
  5. Pick something obscure. Punching down at a famous flop can feel mean. A forgotten paperback with a cover featuring a lone wolf and a lighthouse? Fair game.

The rules matter because the trend could easily curdle into cruelty. The best clubs treat the whole thing as a shared joke, not a takedown. The authors are usually absent—and often unaware. That’s the point. It’s literary criticism by people who are not literary critics, delivered with the warmth of a friend group mocking a bad movie.

Why It’s Working in 2026

The timing makes sense. Streaming has trained people to watch bad movies together and narrate them. Social media has made “one-star review” a genre of comedy. And the reading economy is exhausting: endless best-of lists, aspirational stacks, books chosen for how they look on a coffee table. Bad-book clubs offer a low-stakes alternative. You don’t have to be well-read. You just have to be willing to read something ridiculous and talk about it.

Libraries and indie bookstores have noticed. Some now host “bad book” nights alongside author events, leaning into the idea that reading can be social without being solemn. Bars are a natural venue. So are living rooms. In Austin, one club pairs meetings with a bracket-style tournament to crown the worst book of the year. In Brooklyn, another keeps a running list of “sentences we will never recover from.” The jokes travel because the format is portable: all you need is a bad book and a few people willing to admit they finished it.

Not Mean, Just Honest

The wholesome part is the permission. A bad-book club lets readers say “I hated this” without feeling like a philistine. It also makes room for the weird, the amateur, and the gloriously unedited. In an era of algorithmic recommendations and five-star ratings, there’s something refreshing about a group that deliberately seeks out the bottom of the barrel. The books may be terrible. The evenings are not.

At the Denver bar, the group eventually stops arguing about the detective who smelled evidence with his eyes. Someone reads a passage about a “cavernous pause.” Someone else suggests it would make a great band name. The book gets a rating of zero stars, but the meeting gets five. That’s the trade the bad-book club is making in 2026: suffer the prose together, and the prose becomes a story worth telling.

All Articles

Related Articles

Your Abandoned Novel Is in a Museum Now — and Strangers Are Crying Over It

Your Abandoned Novel Is in a Museum Now — and Strangers Are Crying Over It

Your Library Card Now Comes With a Bundt Pan — and a Waitlist

Your Library Card Now Comes With a Bundt Pan — and a Waitlist

The Envelope Full of Nothing: Inside 2026’s Stranger-to-Stranger Junk Mail Clubs

The Envelope Full of Nothing: Inside 2026’s Stranger-to-Stranger Junk Mail Clubs